About the Author

Scott BalesI have a strong personal interest in Financial Inclusion through the enablement of innovative technologies. Past roles include the Head of Technology at WING Cambodia and a Mobile Financial Services Consultant with HSL Consulting. Drawing from 10 years experience in Financial Services and vast networks across industry, I work with organisations on strategies and plans to establish build and optimize market offerings. I enjoy close relationships with many of the large International Development organizations.

» More about Scott Bales

Monday, December 19, 2011

Introducing Money Mesh


Times are changing, and the time time for me to bring myself into the new era of publishing is upon us. Over the past few months I have thought long and hard about the appropriate way to establish a platform on which I can say my thoughts, insights and outlook. Which lead me to the desire to build a platform for idea, a platform that would be larger than just myself. A platform that would be open to contributions for the world’s leading minds. That platform is Money Mesh.

The technological, social and cultural developments over the past 10 years have accelerated the global rate of innovation. Today, we are witnessing the seismic demographic shift from a traditional and passive media consumer group to an empowered and anytime-anywhere generation of knowledge creators and community builders.

Recent events have shown that social networks possess the power to enrich everyday encounters and enable political upheavals. Mobile devices have facilitated the anywhere-anytime approach to and availability of services, while extending the reach of the financial ecosystem.

Money Mesh seeks to speak in the midst of these changes and aims to explore the ongoing evolution of how our dynamic human network liveswith its money. This blog/forum/platform will provide timely discussions on themes such as technology innovation, social networks, security, regulation, mobility culture shifts and behavioural change in an increasingly mobile and connected world.

I hope to not only share my experiences and insights on these developments and trends, but also initiate a continuing dialogue with thought-leaders, visionaries and innovators who share my passion for making money more mobile and accessible for everyone.

For those who have followed my publishing over the years, I thank you all for your support, the joinery continues at Money Mesh 

Sunday, December 4, 2011

Time for a change

Apologies for my recent absence from writing. I have been going through a life transition as I move out of Fundamo and into a more creative space, both as a new father and an independent mind. I loved my time at Fundamo, I was exposed to some of the most intelligent people in the industry and thrown into some of the most exciting markets on the planet. 


Over the years I have always wanted to write more... write about my thoughts, insights, visions for the future and general outlook on life. Which I have had the pleasure of doing through this blog. However my since finishing up with Fundamo, my creative juices have been flowing stronger than ever before and given birth to an exciting new part of my writing outlets. In close consultation with a few outstanding industry peers, I have been building an exciting new platform for me to share my work through.


In the coming weeks I will be taking the curtains off a new collaboration tool that will allow me to share not only my words, but also images, videos and ideas with the entire world. I am excited to say, it will be a chance for me to push the boundaries of thoughts more than ever before. I look forward to the support of those around me, and encourage you all to get involved in this exciting change.

Monday, October 3, 2011

Disjointed Eco-System… what's the point?


This morning I had a challenging start to the day, not only was it a Monday, but my NETS FlashPay Card was down to less than one dollar. Which means I can't access public transport until I top it up. So I jumped on the Bus with the aim of paying cash, so I could get to the MRT station where I could top up my card. But… Singaporean buses don't accept anything over a Two Dollar note, I only had a Ten. Frustrated, I now had to walk in Singapore's humid morning to the 7-Eleven, roughly half way to the MRT Station. During those 15 minutes I kept thinking in amazement that a bus driver was unable to accept anything more than a two-dollar note. He wasn't even willing to let me ride the bus to the MRT station so I could top-up.

Upon arriving at 7-Eleven I hit a major Eco-System limitation with NETS. You can only Top-Up your NETS FlashPay with Cash, you can't use your NETS Card. In complete amazement, I had to now walk out the front of the building to get cash, so I could come back an pay cash to top-up my card. Why would a domestic scheme create such a situation where one of their products can't interact with another? I associate the ideas with imagine you couldn't pay your VISA Credit Card off using your VISA Debit Card. Thus leaving me a super frustrated consumer.

After loosing close to 45 minutes working my way around the various constraints of the system, it leaves me pondering a key question: What is NETS thinking? Have they completely lost any concept of what it means to be a scheme provider? Why would they create products and services that require the consumer to juggle the end-points? I am complete lost as to how such a constraint even exists, surely I am not the only person to come across this.

If you are going to build a domestic scheme eco-system you need to ensure you encapsulate all the eco-systems end-points. Your value add to the flow of money is meant to be secure customer convenience, not to create more challenges. So I end this blog note with a message to the NETS scheme in Singapore. I strongly suggest you re-evaluate the gaps in your current service offering, you need to ensure you give the consumer end-to-end convenience. Not just deliver where you've been able to negotiate favorable commercial agent agreements. Remember it's your brand on the back of all these products, so the consumer will judge NETS, not 7-Eleven, not Guardian and not the MRT. NETS are responsible for end-to-end experience and convenience. Taking this into account might actually help create a more complete and completive offering.

Monday, September 19, 2011

A new generation of banking... Movenbank



Today we witnessed a quantum step forward for the banking industry, as author of Bank 2.0, Brett King, announced the launch of Movenbank. A radically different way for people to engage with their money. Long gone are the formalities of banking, allowing consumers the power to spend, save and access their money in completely new ways. Utilising the power of gameification, consumers will have transparent power in their hand, known as CRED.

The modern consumer already carries one of the most powerful service delivery devices in the history of man, the mobile phone. Which has amazing ability to create behavioural, geographical, demographic and timeliness information that contextualized the world around us. Just like the daily ritual 750 million Facebook users have, as they check their news feed to see what's going on with their friends, family and associates. Advertising is targeted with precision, suggested services, new friends, all are built leveraging the power of information.

Movenbank has is the bank redesigned for the modern day, in a world that consumers create, engage and utilise information in an increasingly more rapid and empowering ways. Many of the the modern day digital natives have embraced the power of Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn, etc. changing the by gone perception that everyone wants to hide from the world. Instead the modern consumer is happy to agree to an exchange of value, where the consumer allows the world access to their information in exchange for an optimised, contextualized consumer experience. Thus empowering the consumer with the utility of money and their mobile.

Movenbank is based on "CRED," which is based not just on your traditional credit scores, but recognises your "influence" at the bank, through the inclusion of information from your transactional behaviour, social networks and network influence.

With the Alpha release on October 1st. This truly will alter the course of how we all live with our money.

Best of luck to Brett King and the team at Movenbank




Wednesday, September 14, 2011

Breathe… A Tribute to the Mobile Money Pioneers


This year is the ten year anniversary of mobile's entry in the world of financial services. The past ten years has seen the industry push through the phases of experimentation, isolated adoption and the fight for self sufficient viability. Conceived in the unbanked territories of Africa, mobile technologies first primary role was that of an enabler that stretch beyond the boundaries of traditional banks and financial institutions, to reach the underhand and unbanked. What happened would put two industries on a collision course of customer ownership, banking and telecommunications. Many would credit Safaricom's M-Pesa as the first, but prior to M-Pesa's success in Kenya, Celpay in Zambia, G-Cash in the Philippines and Wizzit in South Africa were making inroads. Blue sky dreams lead a hype driven outlook, banks begun to feel the pressure of disintermediation, as mobile operators on multiple continents launched their own flavour of financial services.
Since these early days the evolving industry has had to frantically fight for its survival amongst the absence of matured profitable businesses to justify the ongoing innovation and development costs. The industry attracted only those most passionate about the cause, as they endured complex projects and intense travel schedules in the face of constant criticism from the incumbent financial institutions and regulators.

Recent years have seen a handful of banks launch services, under innovative new business models, such as Wing by ANZ in Cambodia, bKash by Brac Bank in Bangladesh and Barclay's in India. With the banks onboard, regulators around the world began to see the value in agency and branchless banking models, which opened the door for dozens of new operations around the world. Then came 2011.

This year we witnessed major global organisations make large strategic moves, bringing globally recognisable brands and diluting previous doubts about mobile's viability, thus setting the stage for one of the most exciting years ahead. 2012 will see services go mainstream, bridging the gaps between traditional financial eco-systems and the closed loop eco-systems built over the past 10 years. As mobile penetration continues to rapidly grow in all corners of the globe, the markets ability to leverage the mobile network as a part of the financial ecosystem strengthens. Lessons learned from developing and developed markets will collide as individuals that have endured the hard slog to today begin to share knowledge with a broader more engaged audience and workforce.

Gone are the days of frantically trying to justify our existence. Those who don't listen now will be left behind. No doubt, that in years to come 2011 will be seen as a critical tipping point in the evolution of financial services. Those who made moves in 2011 will be the leaders of tomorrow, while those who haven't will be left wondering how they missed the boat.

Now is the time that I'd like to recognise the efforts of the industries pioneers, those that have helped drive the establishment of this evolution. While names are not necessary, I know that these individuals have worked diligently, passionately and exhaustively over the years. Many of which I have had the pleasure of working beside, or shared stories with over the years. I commend your efforts… and encourage you to take this moment to just breathe… reflect and soak up all that you have achieved. The road ahead will still be hard work, but you can rest assured, the industry now has mainstream validation and you are the individuals that carry all the wisdom into this exciting new world.

Congratulations on a job well done

Wednesday, August 24, 2011

Here comes the bride… but who is the bride, and why are they getting married?


Two key industry vertical in the Mobile Financial Services domain are Banks and Mobile Operators, to date they have been in a perceived turf war as they battle over who will prosper as mobile technology strives forward as a key enabler for banking and payments.

The battle was first outlined by the success of SafariCom in Kenya, who with little to no help from the banking sector, built a hugely successful payments services driving huge leaps forward in payments convenience, financial inclusion and of course fee revenue. This lead to the hype driven years where innovators and analysts talked up the market opportunity globally. Moments later, Globe Telecom in the Philippines saw accelerated growth with it's business G-Cash, followed by Smart. But this created an industry divide and challenge. Traditionally banks were the only ones to offer payments and banking services, but recent successes opened the door to the possibility that a non-bank organisations could offer financial services to a customer base far greater than the banks have ever experienced through their traditional bricks and mortar business'. Banking analysts and banks responded with an attempt to create a scare campaign based on consumer protection and fraud, but mobile operator lead initiatives thrived through market necessity. Thus creating and 'Us versus Them' debate throughout the industry. Materials in the press continually focused on the question, 'Who will win?' will it be the Banks,  or will it be the Mobile Operators? A debate with a poisonous thread in an industry that necessitated collaboration.

Throughout the debate we were faced with a choice on whose perspective was right. Were the banks justified in their concerns about security, risk and fraud. Or were the Mobile Operators justified in their risk relative market demand approach providing services to people historically excluded from formal financial services? Reminds me of the dating scene, where men and women have different perspective on conduct and interaction. Even though both had the long term goal of procreation, often self indulgent perspectives encouraged each side that their needs and thoughts are superior and the opposite sex is just wrong. Isn't that what the book Men are Mars and Women are from Venus is based on? Variations on perspective.

Hundreds of years of experience have shaped of legacy thinking and beliefs system of bankers(men) throughout the world. Dealing with people's money was a serious business, with serious risk's. Loosing even a single dollar of a customer is considered devastating both from a reputation and trust perspective. The complexities of modern financial products, have meant that banking has become more than deposits, as increasing numbers of consumers took on credit and investment products. Experience with cheque fraud, financial melt downs, defaults and increased operating costs gave birth to practises such as Basel, AML/CTF, Risk Assessments and Regulated Policy. The result is an industry that fears change, particularly change it doesn't understand. Hence they innovate at a slower pace, prioritise risk controls above customer experience and withdrew from perceived risky products. Banks in my opinion are the men. Historically has reenforced their superiority in society, gentlemanly norms regulated their behaviour, they owned the family assets, drove the family car and women went meant to be subservient. In the end game of procreation, their role as a father is known.

Mobile Operators on the other hands are young in comparison. The earliest commercial mobile phones date back to the late 1970's. Hence they are considerably more innovative, and attack markets at a faster pace. In merging markets, it's not unheard of for operators to have double digit year on year growth. They have endured the markets ability to accept small slips in service standards, adopting multiple iterations of innovations such as SMS, WAP, Smart Phones & 3G. The ever growing demand for communications with mobility have driven their success in their contribution to society. While the comparison is a long shot, the age of the mobile movement is very similar to that of the female movement as women moved out of a stereotyped role in society to contribute in ever increasing capacities throughout society. Many would argue that the individuals drove the feminist movement, but in my opinion global demands necessitated more significant contributions from females arose the world. As the role of a woman grew, so did the frequency in which they stepped on the toes of traditional roles for men(Banks). While they may have moved into corporate roles, equal opportunity and business leaders, their role in society's ultimate goal of procreation remained. But they still had to battle the perception that women couldn't be in serious roles, creating concepts such as the glass ceiling.

What's the comparative for procreation in the battle of Banks and Mobile Operators in the turf war over Mobile Financial Services? One would argue that the effective collaboration between these two industry verticals. In my opinion recent examples of joint ventures, merges and collaboration agreements are the 'marriage' of industry players Leading to the optimum procreational outcome of profitable, sustainable businesses, the children of collaboration. Only through the proliferation of the next generation with evolved perceptions on the norms that govern society, paving the way for more and more successful collaborations.

In summary, I believe the ultimate success and evolution of of mobile technology as a norm for banking and payments is highly dependant on the ability of banks(men) and mobile operators(women) to realise they both have the same objective of building success mobile financial services businesses(children). Only then with aligned horizons will they fuse their roles in the industry, giving birth to generations of industry success

Monday, August 15, 2011

Google & Motorola.... anything for Mobile Money?

In a bid to strengthen its mobile business, Google announced today that it would acquire Motorola Mobility Holdings, the cellphone business that was split from Motorola, for US$40 (S$48) a share in cash, or US$12.5 billion.(TodayONLINE). The offer - by far Google's largest ever for an acquisition - is 63 per cent above the closing price of Motorola Mobility shares on Friday. Motorola manufactures phones that run on Google's Android software.


But is this deal likely to effect the world of Mobile Financial Services? To gain an insight into the potential we need to look at the history of the two businesses.
Motorola has had a roller coaster history over several decades. Many of us would recall devices such as the StarTAC and the RAZR, under the Helo Moto messaging. But even with these pinacle devices, Motorola was never able to achieve the mass market scale of its competitors Nokia, LG and Sony Ericsson. The first Motorola device to use Google's open source OS, Android 2.0, was released on November 2009, the Motorola Droid. The handset division was then spun off into the independent Motorola Mobility.


Google on the other hand has been on an ever growing distribution base in the Mobile OS space since it's acquisition of Android in 2005. Then with the support of the Open Handset Alliance, Google launched it's first release of the acquired platform in 2007. Since that Android has seen a spike in distribution across some 80 device manufacturers. By the fourth quarter of 2010, Android become the world's best selling Mobile OS.


The challenge for Smart Phone OS providers, has always been the market share limitation globally. In 2011, roughly only 25% of global devices are smart phones. This is where the Google Motorola opportunity comes in.
With Motorola's device experience, Google should be able to create move to penetrate lower down the value chain of the handset market. Thus opening the door for richer distribution of services over the open source OS market. With mid and low end devices powered by Android in the hands of the 700 million mobile users in India, or the 180 million in Indonesia, the distribution of mobile service becomes easier and richer. A perspective very different to Nokia's recent announcement of factory preloaded applications.


A parallel initiative run by the Grameen Foundation, AppLab, who seek to engage with organisations, government entities and socially-minded companies interested in better understanding and meeting the needs of the poor. AppLab has had a long history of building services on the Android platform, particularly in markets such as Uganda, Indonesia. Overlaying Google's OS, Motorola's device experience and grass roots level programs such as AppLab's means a powerful network of organisations with simple tools that can overcome the commercial barriers that Mobile Operators put in place to restrict the success of services trying to access their customer base. Resulting in the easier, quicker and more cost effective creation, distribution and management of mobile services such as Mobile Money.


In summary, with the effective collaboration of open source OS(Google) and a device manufacturer(Motorola), we have for the first time, a complete non-Apple mobile eco-system for the creation of services for delivery over mobile



Thursday, August 4, 2011

Recipes to Success #1: Building the EcoSystem


Over the years, I am continually asked what is the 'secret sauce', 'silver bullet' or 'killer app' to ensuring Mobile Money success. And I have to admit, there is no secret, there is only the ability to learn from the repeated mistakes and successes of those that have pioneered before you. Such an approach isn't specific to emerging markets, developed markets, Africa or Asia, but it is a strong set of learnings that one should investigate, understand and consider when making their own play in mobile financial services. One of the key successful factors is understanding and building the eco-system.

Far too many mobile money businesses go head first into launching products that have little market research and little consumer understanding on the chance that 'build it and they will come' or 'copy M-Pesa' will ensure success. Operations like these are continually faced with disappointing adoption rates, or low active utilisation. Thus leaving executives puzzled or disillusioned on around the hype of mobile for financial services.

Building the Eco-System is at the top of my list of insights as a theme that many forget. This may sound simple and straight forward, but one needs to be aware this is not something you can buy, outsource or ignore. It's a constant journey of discovery, adaptation and refinement. It doesn't finish upon launch, nor does it finish within the first year. Best of all, it a journey that will engage you in the fascinating exploration of cash and transaction flows within your market. It involves understanding the various actors within the community, how and why they interact, where they interact, what is the relationship between them. Only with this level of understanding will the market opportunity for Mobile Money be obvious. This could be as simple as witnessing the amount of cash that friends or family send between each other via trusted couriers, or huge queues at a factory on payday. This is your secret sauce, engaging and understanding the world people live in, then finding the points in the ecosystem that could be better.

I have such a recipe, which I have used dozens of times to guide the industry towards success. Engage, Penetrate, Accessibility, Control, Sustain & Learn, Re-Plan, and re-Execute. Let's take a look at each step:

1. Engage: 
First and foremost you must find a way to get amongst your target market. Spend time understanding their everyday needs, pressures, movements, etc. Find out how much cash they carry, and why that amount. Where they travel regularly to buy things, get services, or exchange money? Document everything you find, take photos, exchange contact details. These people will be key in your journey of market understanding and service refinement.

2. Penetrate: 
With a clearer understanding of the market, document your theories on where you feel a service can penetrate the ecosystem. Remembering commerce and financial transaction already happen, your just looking for gaps where you feel a service might enhance or benefit those involved. Start by listing just a dozen. This list is where you make a soft launch of the service. Get those people deeply engaged, because they will be your champions over time.

3. Accessibility: 
Okay, so now you have a few theories on getting into the ecosystem, but you have to remember, once you convert transactions from cash to virtual money, such in the cause of Mobile Money. Those individuals brave enough to be early adopters will need assurance that they can still get access to their money. There is no point trying to address the payday queues at a factory, if the only way they can get cash is to travel to a bank or ATM to make a withdrawal. The access needs to be within their current life & ecosystem, but of course you already know where their life happens from your engage findings.

4. Control: 
While hyper growth is fantastic, it also means you have to scale your service foot print to meet the demand, which creates a risk that you have poor customer experiences outside your existing field of service. Take Facebook for example, they executed a carefully controlled launch, one university at a time. During the initial phases of your launch you will learn ten fold from your original market engagement findings. The ecosystem in which you activate needs to be readily accessible so you can quickly collect market feedback. Make sure you document this feedback, as it will be extremely valuable as you refine the service offering.

5. Sustain & Learn: 
As the ecosystem organically grows, you need to maintain your engagement so that you may observe it grow patterns, behavioural usage, challenges, etc. Ongoing observation and documentation.

6. Re-Plan: 
Revisit the theories you had during the penetrate phase and add to the list, no doubt the number of theories you now have are double or even triple. You need to link your findings in the field in a cyclical manner enabling a highly engaged feedback mechanism into your market planning, service planning and penetration plans. These will be key as you enter more and more ecosystems. Don't be afraid you remove the theories that didn't work, just don't forget why didn't work.

7. Re-Execute: 
This is where the model completes the cycle. Go back and re-engage, whether that is engaging a new ecosystem, or reengaging the same but broader community. You'll enter with an enhance understanding, which will make you more observant and in tune with the community.

This all may seem fairly straight forward, but you'd be surprised how often companies looking to enter the Mobile Money space forget to engage the ecosystem and learn through a repeatable process. The process is scalable, so as your team size grows the process remains with a greater power as you gain more and more perspectives on the market.

So there you have it. A Jamie Oliver style recipe for success in launching Mobile Money. If you'd like ore details, I am always not to far away.

Thursday, June 9, 2011

VISA & Fundamo... Game Changing


Fundamo CEO.
Hannes van Rensburg

Today, VISA Inc announced the acquisition of Fundamo (http://corporate.visa.com/media-center/press-releases/press1128.jsp). You would have read in recent posts that the industries largest players, continue to make large strategic moves in 2011. Today was very different, today VISA 100% acquired Fundamo. Yes, I know this blog is going to sound bias given I work for Fundamo. But I assure you, my person opinion prevails here.

Fundamo has worked hard to develop themselves as an industry leader in the Mobile Financial Services space under the guidance of industry heavy weight, Hannes van Rensburg. They've endured multiple iterations within the industry, as it moved from experimental first movers, to the mature enterprise platforms we see today. The GSMA recognises their customer Celpay in Zambia, as the oldest Mobile Money operation in the world, pre-dating M-Pesa, G-Cash and Wizzit. Fundamo's poster child has always been the deal with MTN Group, which saw Fundamo technology deployed in multiple countries. This was a partnership that fused the might of a Mobile Operator Group in multiple emerging markets, with the thought leadership of the team at Fundamo. Thus creating one of the world's leading multi-country Mobile Money businesses, something M-Pesa has been unable to achieve with Vodafone, and Orange still struggles with.

VISA on the other hand operates the largest payments network in the world with roughly 40% of the worlds Credit Card market and just of 60% of the debit card market. Recent years have seen VISA push deeper into emerging markets with PrePaid products, such as their deployment into Pakistan for the distribution of flood relief funds. VISA has also launched products such as VMT (VISA Money Transfer) which taps into the P2P markets. They also recently invested in CyberSource and PlaySpan, adding to their partnerships with Monitise & Device Fidelity.

The acquisition of Fundamo integrates a industry leading mobile financial services platform, with existing presence in countries across Africa and Asia, into Visa’s global network. Thus bringing to market the first open door for the previously closed loop payments ecosystems that have dominated Mobile Payments to date. Creating a new market potential, far greater than VISA has seen before, and creating a tipping point to drive consumer adoption of mobile as a payment instrument. This move is a true game changer. It means that VISA products can now be extended to the 4 billion plus mobile users world wide, including the highly aspirational emerging nations with greater the 100 Million population.

This announcement when coupled with VISA's complementary assets in the industry is sure to be a success. It essentially gives them all the tools they need to deliver on their May 11th announcement, VISA unveils next generation electronic payments (http://corporate.visa.com/media-center/press-releases/press1124.jsp) only with Fundamo, it now has the footprint to drive deep into emerging economies. 

Exciting times ahead

Friday, May 27, 2011

Google, MasterCard, Citi & First Data.... Fail to deliver on potential

It's out.... Google & MasterCard's Mobile Payments announcement has been formally announced and the industry is now in a hype as opinion pieces, scrutiny and scandals hit blogs & twitter.


But what surprises me most is that the announcement falls short of my expectations. As I mentioned in my post yesterday, Google could have leveraged the Open Handest Alliance and Open Standards of its Android platform to raise the industry to a level that would be hard to follow. We could have seen the possibility of open source developers building ePOS Apps for businesses, driving digital transactions into new market segments where traditional POS devices are too costly. 


Google could have created an offering that goes beyond the limitations of NFC, but have been happy with MasterCard PayPass' NFC network. Is this just a speed to market play from the Google & MasterCard? Or is this actually their strategy?


Let's hope that this is just a speed to market play, otherwise Google & MasterCard have under-estimated the potential of their current assets.

Thursday, May 26, 2011

Google & MasterCard... combining strengths


Google has dominated news in the payments space over the past few days, as the rumors and industry hype pushes toward the confirmation that Google is set to introduce a mobile payments platform that will turn its Android smartphones into a digital wallet. Google invited reporters to attend a "partner event" on Thursday in New York to demonstrate what it called its "latest innovations." It plans to unveil a mobile payments system that will run on the Android operating system and be available on phones from Sprint Nextel Corp, Bloomberg reported on Tuesday. The Internet search and online advertising gorilla will work with MasterCard Inc, the card processing network, to launch the system they told Reuters on Tuesday. A separate repost in the Wall Street Journal suggest Citigroup is also in on the action. That's three household names partnering to capture your digital wallet, three names with equally powerful market size and presence to shift the market towards mainstream adoption.


Many would have also read VISA's announcement back on May 11, demonstrating their ambitions and plans to build a global digital wallet service due to hit the market later this year. Visa’s mobile wallet initiative really could revamp the way we spend money, and the way we interact with our smart phones. Similar attempts have been initiated in the past by handset manufacturers, mobile operators, public infrastructure, but never made their way to the mainstream market. Hopefully, we’ll get to see what the future may look like as soon as this year, assuming Visa sticks to the outlined plan.


As Google prepares their announcement, lets look at the value each of the partners brings to the table. Firstly their is no questioning the role of MasterCard in the venture, they currently have the world's second largest card processing network, behind VISA's. But their scale is far from insignificant. MasterCard operates Banknet, a global telecommunications network linking all MasterCard card issuers, acquirers and data processing centers into a single financial network creating a global footprint that creates a network that would comfortable touch a large majority of the world's smart phone owners, creating an compelling case for moving your MasterCard connection from the cards in your wallet to your Android Smart Phone. Adding to the value of the network MasterCard has PayPass, an EMV "contactless" payment feature, which could foreseeably be delivered via a mobile device, currently available in many of MasterCard’s issuing bankcards. MasterCard has an estimated 190 million cards in circulation in the United States alone, 960 million worldwide.


Google on the other hand provides on of the worlds most popular mobile operating systems. Google acquired Android Inc. in August 2005, making Android Inc. a wholly owned subsidiary of Google Inc. and selected at the OS of choice by Google when they launched themselves into the Mobile Operating System market. The first commercially available phone to run the Android operating system was the HTC Dream, released on 22 October 2008. In November 2007 a powerful consortium was formed that could play am important part in Google's announcement. The founding of the Open Handset Alliance, a consortium of 80 hardware, software, and telecom companies devoted to advancing open standards for mobile devices, including Broadcom Corporation, Google, HTC, Intel, LG, Marvell Technology Group, Motorola, Nvidia, Qualcomm, Samsung Electronics, Sprint Nextel, T-Mobile and Texas Instruments. Creating a diverse, powerful network of manufacturers that collaborate under the message of open software. A very different approach to Apple's single manufacturer and tightly guarded source code approach.


It's estimated in Q2 2009 that Android had a 2.8% share of worldwide smartphone shipments, but by Q4 2010 this had grown to 33% of the market, becoming the top-selling smartphone platform. In May 2010, Android's first quarter U.S. sales surpassed that of the rival iPhone platform. At Google I/O, May 10, 2011, Google announced that 400,000 new Android devices are activated every day and more than 100 million have been activated.


The initiative from Google & MasterCard has now signed up retail partners Macy's Inc., American Eagle Outfitters Inc. and Subway, though it is unclear the scope of the US deployment. Will this be another industry pilot?


What does all this mean? I see this as a re-confirmation that 2011 is the year of the Mobile Wallet. Big brands making big moves, ones that are far beyond pilots and experimentation. This announcement, along with VISA's states to be the Mobile Payments industry tipping point driving mainstream adoption globally. My personal hope is this drives a global replacement of the cards issuing networks, creating a simplified financial & payments life for all consumers. By separating our society from the legacy infrastructure of cards & POS devices, the networks of MasterCard, VISA, American Express can penetrate deeper into the under and unbanked parts of the world. It should also be the catalyst for the reduction of overheads for payments, leading to cheaper payments services.


One possibility that still remains unknown is how Google's open standards approach will impact the way we all do payments. It could lead to the possibility of open source POS Apps being built for Android devices, creating an opportunity for Android to replace the millions of POS devices and machines worldwide. One thing for sure, is the open standards will gain a heightened level of scrutiny over security, encryption and privacy.


In summary, I think this is a very positive move by two large complementary industry players combining their strengths, network and consumer foot print. I guess we will have to wait to hear the details of VISA's announcement to know how far they have taken their vision & plans. In my opinion, if VISA is to raise the bar on MaserCard, they make a deal with Facebook, putting a VISAnet Connected Wallet behind the 600 million Facebook users, and giving Facebook's Merchant plans global network strength.

Friday, May 20, 2011

Proof: Social Networks are Viable Commercial Businesses

Many of us would have read in the news today that LinkedIn(LNKD), the online professional networking platform, had an overly successful IPO with their shares going for up to USD 120 after opening at pricing at just USD 45 before opening. An astounding achievement for an small internet start-up, in a time where social networks come under continual scrutiny over their commercial value.


The success of LinkedIn's IPO now fuels the rumor mill as companies like Facebook, Groupon, Pandora, Kayak and other look to launch their own Public Offerings in the coming year. Could any of these repeat the success of LinkedIn, or are we witnessing a bubble created by first mover advantage. One this is for sure, LinkedIn's Market Capital has accelerated beyond many individuals wildest dreams. So now we can all get in on the action, as retail investors buy up stock in a previously dreary Tech Stock market.

Monday, May 9, 2011

Financial Institutions in Disruption & Innovation

Mobile Technology has posed one of the more disruptive changes to the Financial Services industry in decades. It will rewrite the expectations of consumers and their needs from their financial intuition. Suddenly 24x7 accessibility, instant fulfillment, enriched contextual service, simplicity and mobile will be the trend of tomorrow's successful retail bank. But what is stopping the banks from making these moves today? It's not a technology limitation, because all the necessary tech is already available. Is it the legacy mindset of the banks? I think so.


The banking sector has one huge thing going for it. It has survived multiple depressions, recessions, revolutions, evolutions and innovations. Their slow but steady approach to progress protects them from hype, risk and bad decisions (except in recent times). So how does an traditionally risk adverse intuition position itself fo future success? There are several cases of success. 


Take for example Australia & New Zealand Bank's transformational subsidiary in Cambodia, WING. A business aimed specifically at a new market segment for the bank on a technology the bank had little experience with, mobile. Big establishing a separate brand & operations, ANZ was able to protect the Mothership while experimenting with a new approach to the market. Similarly National Australia Bank, used the UBank venture to dable in new generation direct banking.


So will we see more experiments like these as banks grapple with with the evolving Generation M as they push into primary markets? I would suggest so, as it allows the Traditional Bank to survive, while creating a the ability to learn new technologies and customer needs.

Saturday, April 30, 2011

VISA Squared... what are the possibilities of VISA & Square


As per my pervious blog posts, the Mobile Financial Services industry is hyped with frequent merges and acquisitions currently. The most recent being VISA's move to take an interest in Square, Twitter inventor Jack Dorsey's disruptive mobile payments service.


First, let's take a look at Square. Square combines two services, an electronic payment service, and a card-reading device that simply plugs into the headphone jack of your iPhone, iPad or Android phone. Allowing users in the US to accept credit cards payments through their mobile phones, either by swiping the card on the Square device or by manually entering the details on the phone (Wikipedia, 2011). The business model offered is simple:



  • Free card reader. Free app for iPhone, iPad & Android.
  • Get Paid through VISA, MasterCard, American Express & Discover Card, directly into your bank account.
  • All for only 2.75% per transaction.
  • The services requires no contract and no ongoing commitments.



Think that will scare the banks, who currently make millions in Merchant Acquiring solutions? Or will it scare the Ingenico's & Verifone's of the world to realise they are about to be disinter-mediated on a device front? Personally I think it's brilliant. It's a key step in sunsetting the legacy infrastructure that burdens the modern consumers payments networks with proprietary expensive devices. Instead a payments accepter just needs an iPhone, iPad or Android device. Last quarter Square did $66 million in payment volume and plans to triple that this quarter, and that's just in the US.


To date Square has needed to cross one of the toughest bridges in the financial services industry, it needed buy-in from the industry, which is highly regulated and has barriers to entry. VISA taking an stake in Square goes a long way to legitimising Square's technology. If VISA and Square can work to develop a VISA certified device, I'd suggest wide scale adoption will happen, fast! Particularly in the Small to Medium Business sector where the cost of current Point of Sale Merchant services are not as attractive. What else legitimises Square's disruptive approach is the appointment of an exec from JP Morgan, which is Square's US payments partner.


One the broader vision of Mobile Financial Services, this move by VISA should be seen as a strong one. One of the key challenges of using mobile devices for point-of-sale payments is the change in consumer behaviour shifting from Plastic Cards & POS Devices to a mobile to mobile transaction. If VISA can drive mass adoption of the Square reader, the market would be quickly taken through a perception change as they witness an increasing amount of merchants using a mobile phone, therefore building confidence over time in the technology. Thus creating a more sustainable stepping stone for the longer consumer adoption of mobile as a payments instrument.


It's only a matter of time then until the card is replaced by a service, NFC, Application or other, in the consumers handset. Creating mobile to mobile point of sale. From there the possibilities are endless.


Great move by VISA

Thursday, April 28, 2011

Single Sign On in a Mobile World

Over a period of time the concept of Single Sign On has pushed its way into the very core of how an organization looks at User Authentication. This includes the Global Banks with infinitely high security standards, policies and procedures. 

In the modern company, an employee logs onto their Domain account once, which opens to the door to an endless amount of corporate applications such as Email, Intranet, Finance Systems, Customer Systems and more. This approach means that user authentication, and security policy can move to a central function. So when the security policy for password expiry changes from 60 days to 30 days, the policy is only changed in one place and instantly applies to all users and all systems.

But how can this authentication experience be replicated in the Mobile world? How can a method of identifying an individual be securely deployed and managed, when a users primary device of interaction is their mobile phone?

A solution to this challenge has so many applications. Mobile Executives could use it to be always available on corporate workflow tools, such as Account Payable, or business processes that require executive approval; Consumers could have a single trusted authentication mechanism which opens the door to dozens of cloud services such as Facebook, Banking, Shopping, Memberships; Mobile could then be used as a primary authentication for virtually any service. Imagine a world where your mobile is locked by a bank grade PIN, just like your ATM card is today. But instead of only granting you access to your Card at an ATM or POS, the PIN unlocks your phone and along with some internal authentication a user can access Facebook, Email, etc all as a trusted user. Therefore negating the need for a user to manage multiple user name & password relationships. With such a trusted mechanism in place, a consumer could enter a shop, purchase goods, wave their Mobile Phone with NFC, a payment request is pushed to the users phone to approve the payment using their PIN. This would enhance the application of NFC to cover larger value transactions other than public transport.

Take the idea further, a consumer would wave their Mobile Phone to access doors, and where necessary additional authentication is requested of the user in more secure sensitive situations. Therefore removing the need for the work issued security card, instead the employees electronic ID in their Mobile is registered and used as the primary means for identifying who they are. The same can be used for to access your home, and while your at it, you house recognizes your home and adapts to your preferences, turns on heater, switches on the TV to the news with items specific to you similar to your Facebook or Twitter account.

The reality is all the technology to do this exists today. NFC is now standardized, door readers exist in a large majority of corporate buildings, 500 million of us have Facebook and 100 million have Twitter, Secure USSD PIN requests can be sent to a Mobile Phone authenticating at a physical level that you are you, you have your registered SIM card(MSISDN/ICCID), you are using the same Mobile Handset(IMEI) and you are located(GPS) in a place that suggests you are actually the person requesting the service. But why are we not seeing this wide adoption of innovative eco-systems to enable this? The answer is turf protection. The NFC guys aren't openly talking to the door security companies, who aren't advising their customer to adopt an open authentication. The banks are still caught up on understanding mobile, let along embracing its true power. And no one, and I mean NO ONE has looked to fully utilize the power of Facebook as a global means to identify someone and their preferences.

Anyone want to give it a go? I am keen :)

Friday, April 15, 2011

Merging Lanes

The past six months have seen some interesting changes to the industry of Mobile Financial Services. Over the past 5 years I have endured the long haul of taking an immature experimental industry as it drives towards the ambition of one day going mainstream. Recently, large brands have made public announcements to commitments to either implement or acquire. The vendor space has seen a succession of acquisitions, such as Sybase into SAP, m-Com into Fiserv. The line between Banked and Underbanked has been blurred, as wallet based transactional businesses strive to increase the financial intuitions share of the consumer's wallet.


But what has this translated to on the ground? Realistically, nothing. The industry challenge of scale still remains. Hence the question remains: which one of these moves will eventuate in a highway to scale, and eventually the mainstream adoption of Mobile as a means for Financial Services.


I think the answer to this question lies in understanding the history of the industry. The past ten years has seen several successes and failures, but there are some very key themes to success. First and foremost those who have succeeded appreciate the difference between bank based architecture and telco based architecture. As the number of consumers in the market increases, bank principles such as financial integrity, reconciliation, risk management and consumer protection have ensure businesses avoid some of the traps of the mobile operator approach to transaction processing.


Secondly, a senior commitment to vision is critical as a player enters the market with a new service, as this commitment will be essential for the business to drive consumer engagement, effective launch campaigns and ongoing consumer adoption. This stuff doesn't happen overnight, nor does it happening easily.


So what's my tip for the year to come, look for players/partners that have:
1. A strong commitment to the vision of the industry.
2. Have a strong deep history in launching these Mobile Financial Services businesses
3. Understand the principles required in the manufacturing of Financial Products, financial integrity, scalability, risk management, transaction life cycling and consumer protection.
4. Have past experience in consumer understanding and consumer adoption for your specific market


They may sound simple, but you' be surprised how often people miss the obvious.

Friday, March 18, 2011

Green & White. Mobile Money in Pakistan and beyond


This week I traveled into Karachi, Pakistan for the annual Mobile Commerce summit. This year the title sponsor was UBL (United Bank Limited), a new entrant to the Mobile Financial Services domain and one egger to follow in the foot steps of fellow domestic competitors MCB Mobile and easyPaisa. 

This annual event is always a delight to attend and easily pulls Mobile Financials Services heavy weight Hannes van Rensburg, CEO of Fundamo. Pakistan has been good for Fundamo, we have seen great success from two very different approaches to the market. But what impresses me most about Pakistan is showing what has been labelled "The Perfect Storm", a timely coming together of a number of market dynamics in a way that no other country in the world has managed, including Kenya. The country has any number of progressive thinking bankers sitting next to a banking regulator keen to enable healthy competition, in market with all the right demographic indicators. It also had a Telco with a crystal clear vision of how Mobile Money would succeed in Pakistan's unbanked population. The result is two highly successful businesses that openly recognize they have each targeted different segments of the market and that long term, their ecosystems must interact to drive mainstream adoption. Today MCB Mobile & Easypaisa are the benchmark in Pakistan which has inspired action from many of Pakistan's other players.

Another first for the industry was the opening panel session, which saw the Deputy Governor of the State Bank sit next to the Director of the PTA (Pakistan Telecom Authority) and then proceed to publicly speak of real cooperation and a vision for creating a positive healthy regulatory market that not only enables those wishing to enter the Mobile Money space, but also foster healthy competition without creating a fragmented market. Something I am positive was music to the ears of the VISA delegates at the summit.

A true highlight was hearing the story from Zahir on Roshan's Mobile Money journey in neighboring Afghanistan. A country completely war torn after 30 years of war. A country with almost non-existent infrastructure, no land lines, only 45 ATMs of which 43 don't work, very few roads and a hugely informal cash based financial ecosystem. Roshan's journey through this not only opens your eyes to the pure simple perspective of the world as an Afghan, but it also reminds you not to take basic things for granted. Such was the case when Roshan realized that 70% of the Afghan Police Force were illiterate, and hence couldn't read the SMS that told them that their salary had been paid. Or that the police force salary would go up to 35% simply by removing the middleman.

Zahir also spoke of industry evangelist Jan Chip Chase, who recently jumped on a motorbike with a camera and a translator to deeply engage the Afghan people in an effort to understand their needs. Coupled with Jan's amazing photographic skill, this turns out to be one of the most captivating market case study you'll ever read. (The Mobile Frontier http://janchipchase.com/content/presentations-and-downloads/the-mobile-frontier/). A research project that I am sure his former employer's, Nokia, security policies would have frowned upon. Speaking of which, Nokia's Mobile Financial Services unit popped up at the summit with an interesting insight into their vision for bringing enriched customers experience and the value of a handset manufacturer to the Mobile Money ecosystems of Pakistan. Does this mean Nokia Money is coming to Pakistan?

All in all the summit was a positive injection of industry excitement and evidence that even the world's most advanced Mobile Financial Services market is still looking for ways to raise the bar and continue to push to be a benchmark for other countries.

Lastly, a huge thanks goes out to Owais Zaidi from Access Group, who took us out on a local food adventure. Where my taste buds and tummy were shown Nihari with brain and marrow, Rubberi on Burns Road and the famous Paan stalls, the clean versions of course. Adventures like these are key for international professionals to get out of the Hotels and fancy restaurants to see exactly how the locals live.

I look forward to next year, and encourage those in the industry to try and make time to visit Pakistan.

Wednesday, March 9, 2011

On the couch with Rensburg

Yesterday I had the pleasure of spending time with a mentor of mine, Hannes van Rensburg of Fundamo. Hannes and I share a enthusiasm for innovation that sees mobile fused with financial services at a time in which there is limited full scale business's to justify the industry's existence. We will often have discussions that venture into the possibilities and challenges of our chosen field. I thoroughly enjoy these discussions, particularly when the happen at Fundamo HQ in Cape Town. A city that is now close to my heart after developing a personal obsession with their signature wine, the Pinotage.

Relationships like this are rare in the Mobile Financial Services industry, given the relative immaturity of the industry. Thought leaders are usually lightly spread across organizations and usually in competitive situations, such as competing businesses, consultancies or technology vendors. This is a complete contrast to our related industries of either Mobile Telecommunications or Banking, where deep multi-generational maturity provides thought leaders with dozens of options when it comes to industry guidance or visionary discussions. Which leaves us questioning, where pioneers find their inspiration, sound board or mentor in the absence of those with reference experience.

Each thought leader in this space has his personal passion ideas. The ones that manifest over the  years into clear visions that eventually the individual feels compelled to act on. Hannes and I love to bounce the latest state of our ideas off each other, as we close pollinate our knowledge in the ongoing pursuit of our visions.

So I'd like to take a few moments to recognize the individuals that have helped shape who I am today. Their contributions to my development have proven time and time again to be invaluable. Firstly with have Lynn Rock, now in 38th year with ANZ Bank in Australia. This is an inspiring woman that started with the bank back when they had to write manual account journals, but has continued to refresh her mind in the ongoing pursuit of excellence. Lynn has seen technology come and go, but continues to show that you can teach an old dog new tricks.

Joseph Seychell, isn't a always remembered with positivity. But this is a guy that was prepared to challenge the norms of a conservative organization. Joe lead ANZ head first into some crazy thinking such as Monte Carlo risk calculation and consolidated counter party decision making in the highly tense world of financial markets. Joe's imprint on me continues to shine through, as I challenge an industry to adapt, evolve and extend.

Brad Jones, who I actually first meet during my Seychell days, gave me the gift that changed my life. Absolute trust in my abilities. Brad, I and a few others landed in Cambodia to catch a concept known at the time only as SMS Banking. Something that would later become a business close to my heart, WING Money. One of the first Bank Led Mobile Money businesses in the world, and one that would maintain commitment to a socially responsible agenda around financial inclusion. When we landed on the ground we had nothing, and I mean nothing. We had to find offices, buy computers and hire local staff. We were forced to make it up as we went alone, cause there was no precedence for what we were doing. But I loved every moment of it, it stretch the boundaries of my creative mind. Brad trust in me during this time, built an invincible resolve in me to chase the impossible with a belief that anything was possible. It also gives me great pleasure to see Brad continue in the industry.

Only through continuity in the industry will brilliant minds likes these help drive Mobile Financial Services through it's decades of immaturity into a thriving main stream market.

Now time to find a bottle of red

Bridging the success gap... Mobile Money, Emerging Markets to Developed

Many would recognize the amazing success emerging markets have witnessed over the past six years in the deployment and adoption of Mobile Financial Services. We have seen the success of M-PESA in Kenya, followed by the drive of G-Cash in the Philippines. We have seen MTN attack a group wide strategy with absolute conviction, while Pakistan has seen the rise of both Mobile Operator and Bank Led models in a single market. But why has this success never been translated to developed markets? Why have we not seen adoption rates in markets like the US, Europe, and Australia. Because if you look closely at the market, both Uganda and Australis have similar numbers of cash based transactions.

Having personally seen many of these emerging market successes, I feel that the developed world has a great deal to learn from the success of their poorer cousins. But it appears that there is a clear inability to execute on these learnings.

I put a challenge to the world of Financial Services to taken Mobile Money business models of the world and apply it to the US, or the UK, and I think you'll find that if you analyze the numbers, there is a greater chance of ROI in these markets, where transaction amounts are higher and people are willing to pay for convenience. 

But what are these learnings? Here are a few insights that can easily be replicated:
1. Simplified Money services. not complex transactional accounts with a multitude of expensive channels. Just a simple wallet for everyday money needs. Buying milk, the newspaper, a coffee. Small simple transactions.
2. Lighter incentivized eco-systems: Avoid the expense of the current card/POS networks to deploy a lighter POS network that runs across already present mobile devices. And offer incentives in the eco-system that reduce your cost or risk or cash management
3. Replace the cash, not the cards. There have been dozens of attempts to replace the cards we already carry. But we need to look at the cash, why do people carry cash? How do they use it? How can you intermediate these transactions?

Get these three right, and you'll have a successful Mobile Money deployment anywhere in the world, which includes developed countries. I'll even help if there is anyone keen.